jayarsea wrote:
QUOTE FROM NICOLE: I still think that if Bobby is innocent, a No Lynch would have been preferable to killing him off - but you're right that we have no way to know if he was mafia too. /QUOTE
That's completely true. However, you can't know ever /KNOW/ that someone you lynched is innocent...so it's not really something you can really get around.
Well, of course. I'm just responding to your claim that a No Lynch couldn't possibly bring us closer to victory. In this situation, lynching Fluffy or Bobby probably was the right thing to do (I hadn't read last night's discussion when I made my last post. My bad.) - however, in general in this game, with a large number of townspeople compared to a small # of mafia, I feel like a little more caution and less killing people based on unfounded suspicions could go a long way. I'm just not sure that lynching someone every night is the right way to approach this game - there's no way that all of those people can be mafia.