jayarsea wrote:
Because herding cats is really tough.
(We aren't coordinated enough to get everyone to vote the same way, and today we have the tiebreaker edge on Nicole.)
So according to this investigator report (Di is investigator, by the way), either JB or Di is mafia. I'm 99.9% sure it's JB, but let's humor him...
I want to point out that we can...lynch Nicole today and we will be down to 1 mafia and 4 innocents.
NEXT DAY
Assume the mafia manages to kill someone the next day, so we're down to 1-3
We lynch JB.
The NEXT DAY (which shouldn't happen, but iff...)
If he's innocent, it's still 1-2 (he's not innocent though) in favor of the innocents. Di, Mark, and I don't have fake IDs. So Ami/other innocent will have a fake ID (by the pigeonhole principle?). They can cast two votes to make certain that even if the mafia manages to kill one person to make it 1-1, we have the fake ID and the win by tiebreaker. (JB and Nicole will be voting for Di tonight most likely, so she will lose any tiebreaker with tied votes with only two players alive.
PS: You are still invited to sign my petition, JB, unless you believe that there are three mafia members: (Di, Mark, and I)...
Nicole, you can sign also!