Lucy wrote:
Reasons to distrust Daniel:
1) With Lily dead, Daniel's free to make kills without her wondering where he is/why he's typing so much without anything showing up on town square.
2) Making a kill in South Station is brilliant. I bet mafia weren't expecting anyone to gather clues for an investigation (I certainly wasn't). The only person who can get around that is mayor. Lucky for the mafia, Lily was mayor so it'll be a while before a new mayor can investigate it. Daniel was the one who decided Lily should be mayor so it was simple for him to make sure mayor wouldn't be an issue. He also pushed very hard to be mayor originally.
3) He is someone I think would be willing to stake out South Station for mafia.
4) Daniel's alibi doesn't match what the NPs said.
5) As mafia, it makes perfect sense for him to claim Poison. It lulls town into thinking there's no hitman or scheme. It gives him an argument for holding off on getting lynched until Day 3 at the least (Very late game for a game this size)
I will readily acknowledge 1-3 and 5.
But I was in the pit at the time of the kill. I believe the nps where just confused/mistaken about timing.