Yeah, this is a tough one. Added complication that mafia members may or may not be out to get us. We wish the mafia no ill will (beyond give us the hallows/rings and don't fucking kill us), and it seems not unreasonable that they might feel the same. Or they might not know we exist.
My inclination is to trust you guys, simply because the world where I can trust you is a lot more fun than the world where I can't. More strategizing, all that good stuff. Besides, it would be kind of stupid to have a secret council of four people where >=1 of them actually wants to sabotage our goals.
Untrustworthy and I treat you as untrustworthy: Made the right call, but the game gets boring because I can't trust anyone and am not town aligned and thus not invested in their goals Untrustworthy but I treat you as trustworthy: big mistake on my part, I die soon and lose the game. Trustworthy but I treat you as untrustworthy: probably makes us lose the game and miss out on lots of good fun strategizing and collusion Trustworthy and I treat you as trustworthy: best possible world.
|