For Katie's goodwill voting plan, I *think*:
1) CT1 has a 50% chance of being outed (iff they're paired with a town P). But even if they're paired with a mafia P, I think that P should claim honestly and get into a beef with CT1, since CT1 will be outed soon anyway, and we'd rather have the mafia P look good.
2) I don't see how they're going to get much info from the block-of-3-psychiatrists-voting-for-P4-and-P5. There'll be, what, a 4-way beef? If anyone feels like explaining this to me it'd be much appreciated.
3) We won't have much time to figure out claims once the votes are submitted, so (if possible) let's try to do that early. If in doubt about what you should claim as to whether you received a goodwill, I think P4/P5 should lie and P1/2/3/6 should be honest.
Also, for the execution voting, votes are anonymous, so maybe we might as well all vote as a bloc to execute Luke? If by chance we have townies who aren't submitting their votes, this could be an easy win
(By Luke, I mean, either jamb or luke, let's flip a coin.)
Unfortunately this would reveal how many mafia there are and be unlikely to work. Maybe we should have 5 people vote for luke, so it looks like there are exactly 5 mafia? Somehow I don't think town would buy that...