Live Action Mafia

Everybody vote for lucci, NOT ermain.

Lucci is guaranteed mafia. Erin may have been rogue, which is not nearly as important. Lynch Lucci

Lucci is guaranteed mafia. Erin may have been rogue, which is not nearly as important. Lynch Lucci

Maybe I'm confused, but it seems to me that rogues should take priority over any mafia but the last mafia? Erin kills 1/3 people/day, but Lucci kills 0 people/day. The last mafia kills 1 person/day, of course, but even if you amortize, seems to me we should be killing Erin.

But I haven't been as active as really I should be, and there might be a piece of strategy that I might be missing. So I'll defer to other peoples' judgment in my vote.

Adam, I don't understand AT ALL what you're talking about.

This thread is irrelevant, lucci is dead. Lynch ermain.

I second not understanding what Adam is talking about. But I think it's moot?

This thread is irrelevant, lucci is dead. Lynch ermain.

Adam is trying to say: Rogues kill one person every 3 days. The mafia collectively kill one person every day. Therefore killing any single mafioso does not reduce the number of kills per day (unless its the last one, ending the game in which case its moot), whereas killing a rogue does.

Yeah, it's moot, and Justin is right about what I was saying.

Sorry guys

Voting to lynch ermain, though I also think lynching Justin would have been reasonable.