Live Action Mafia

(This is a combination of public and private information. I promise that i am a good guy).

Day 4 Ermain killed Lily, Day 5 Ermain killed Lucy. Ermain made two kills in a row, therefore she must be mafia (and not a rogue). Lucy was grave-dug as mafia. Why would the mafia kill one of their own? I think we need to be a little suspicious of something that is going on here.

cheers
Jacobi

Do rogues and mafia grave dig differently?

Could Frame the Innocent have been used on Lucy?

Plant evidence may have been used on Lucy.

Still doesn't explain how she role-claimed as ironheart but didn't die as one.

Lucy likely false role-claimed as Ironheart. There's nothing wrong with that, even if you're a townsperson.

ksedlar died which means she was clearly a good guy. She personally told me that she shoveled Lucy and that Lucy turned up mafia.

Most likely option: Plant Evidence was used on Lucy.
VERY VERY unlikely option: Frame a Townsperson was used on Ermain (mafia) to appear as though she killed Lilly.

That being said, even the most likely option seems kind of weird. Does anyone have any ideas as to what's going on?

And interpreting the rules literally, grave dig should have revealed Rogue, not Mafia.

Grave dig was used on Lucy. She is actually a mafia.
ermain actually killed Lucy, plant evidence does nothing to mics.
That's all there is.

"Plant Evidence

1 per game, the mafia may send a PM to the moderator of the form, “I plant evidence to make X appear to be role Y,” where X is a dead player, and Y is any role, including “mafia.” X will subsequently appear to be role Y, wherever it is relevant (such as for shovels.)"

plant evidence can be used to manipulate shovels