Live Action Mafia

christmasfutre and kwicks die from inactivity. Game is rebalanced as needed.

There is no execution.

Votes pending...

brunnerj no lynch
Daniel Grazian no lynch
dylanhen no lynch
gurev nolanrei
jakob dylanhen
jamb no lynch
Jason Ye no lynch
Julian dylanhen
ksedlar no lynch
laberca nolanrei
linus no lynch
lucy no lynch
lukesci no lynch
m2w no lynch
maxmurin no lynch
mayars no lynch
mx3 no lynch
ObitoSigma yyao1
pravinas no lynch
python maxmurin
Vito no lynch

everyone else voted for themselves

Random redistribution of evicted player's items:

laberca gets a hymnal!
lukesci gets a shovel!

@python: rude!

Oops was playing Cards Against Humanity past the rollover time. Anyway I would have voted no lynch so it didn't matter.

I feel like random voting is better than no lynch in most situations, on the grounds that no lynch basically gives mafia a free kill, and there is relatively little provable information in-game (pair investigation results can prove people innocent for one kill but that is about it, and the only provable town role is the Child). So imo the main source of intel appears to be alibis or lack therof, and we should thus consider random-lynching a player taken out of the set {players with no alibis or sketchy/unconfirmed alibis}. Hence why I voted more or less randomly last round out of players in this set.

Understandable, but I think that uncoordinatedly lynching these people allows mafia to make it more likely to lynch a town, by not voting for the mafia contained in that set. While it's true that letting the mafia have a free kill is bad, letting them have a free kill and then lynching in a way that benefits mafia is possibly worse.