Ok, yes, we noticed dgrazian and yyao were confirmed too when we were going through the list of players, but forgot about them when making this list.
I was unaware that brunnerj's alibis were confirmed. Nothing on the spreadsheet said so.
I agree that there is absolutely nothing to clear jakob. We skipped ourselves when going through the list of players because there was less of a point in us discussing it, oops.
I think that python's narrative here is a bit of a stretch. The mafia got a free kill, and used it during parallel kill time, and the parallel killer chose not to kill yesterday? Oh I forgot, you explained this away by saying that the PK was roleblocked. There are many reasons I can think of to kill Lucy, none of them are THAT great but:
- Information she had - Role power she had - Someone mentioned to me that irl issues may be related to it - They thought she was the parallel killer and wanted to recruit - They thought she had been cursed the previous day but she hadn't - They wanted to kill investigator pomegranate's alibis: note that this was Lucy and Dylan, both of them died yesterday and we haven't heard from pomegranate since... - They wanted to be able to make this type of argument "well, mafia wouldn't have done this, what can I say actually happened?" - General confusion, similar to above - There was an opportunity to kill her with good alibis to not get caught - Something I can't imagine because I'm not mafia - Some combination of the above
In any case, I think that for example ksedlar's previous claim of "mafia would be dumb to do this; I would never do it, therefore I'm not mafia" is nearly worthless. So my conclusion (and Jack and Jakob's) is that the dylan kill was nearly certainly done by a parallel killer. It's just the simplest explanation really.
"I will bet my life that yyao isn't a PK PI"... if he's a PK as you claim then there's probably slightly better than 1/9 odds of him being PI, not good but I suggest not betting your life.
Here's my personal updated list, without further discussion with Jack and Jakob:
Very suspicious: python Suspicious-ish: chiller, vito, jakob Maybe: Joachim (I think we accidentally skipped him last time oops), a couple others but it's kinda a stretch Confirmed-ish not PK: Jasonlam, maxmurin, laberca, dgrazian, yyao1 Would be surprised: Everyone else
|