sammyluo wrote:
Note that this entire conclusion depends on aok (the first person to propose this idea, in private to me and ksedlar on day 2) being town, as otherwise he could have easily prepared the mafia not to get totems on day 1 to look innocent
This interaction makes me believe aok is pretty strongly updated towards innocent, assuming that katie killed sammy, which I have no reason to distrust. Like, if aok were mafia, I don't really think that he'd have felt the need to loop Sammy in before posting on the forums, especially when he could easily have said he talked it over with katie, without sammy. Therefore I trust aok. That being said, I don't necessarily think that no mafia claimed to be totemless on day 2.