tldr; As I said in the other thread, I also think we should vote no lynch today.
Unless new information comes up, I think our 2 courses of actions are:
1. Vote brunnerj today 2. Vote no lynch today, wait for more investigations tomorrow to confirm/deny the suspicion of brunnerj.
I personally think (2) is a better choice because this is a HIGHLY suspicious kill for brunnerj to make (Killing a player while other people know he will be around+not having any alibi?). This is a very sloppy kill for him to have made, and it points a lot to mafia trying to frame him, knowing he and achester would be at the same meeting. Another point to brunnerj's favor is that achester did not paranoia text about the killer, despite being in the elevator with the killer? This points to someone who achester does not know the face of.
Valid reasons for voting (1): "Being too suspicious" is NOT an entire reason to not vote for someone. There's a high chance that if it's not Josh who killed achester, then he was framed, and we won't gain any useful information about his innocence, and will have to lynch him anyway, burning up any future investigations that we try to use to determine his innocence on a mostly "solved" kill.
Last edited by ixa on Wed Sep 18, 2019 9:42 pm, edited 2 times in total.
|