brunnerj wrote:
We are using ksedlar's douse as an effective second execution. We don't want this to be visible to mafia to avoid manipulation.
We are fine with the execution being visible.
If people have opinions on how to choose the lynch/douse target, they should speak here. I believe we want at least the douse to ultimately be chosen by not more than 2 individuals so mafia don't know what it is.
I recommend we choose approximately randomly among players with no claims.
Like I said earlier I'm still very much not a fan of this -- I'm surprised nobody else is saying this; given that the metas I'm used to will always execute neutral claims on the spot -- since they're just like mafia where if neutrals+mafia form a majority we lose. Even a claim like Survivor merits this... how can we let an Arsonist live?
We also don't know who she doused last night -- for all we know this could be luke, yes? She might get one or two kills off for us in the best-case scenario... is that really worth it? She's probably going to just get roleblocked every night if she's really working with us -- or if she's working with mafia, she'll pretend to be roleblocked every night, and potentially douse people in secret if she thinks she won't be stalked.