Live Action Mafia

You've probably noticed that I PMed you saying "Congratulations on your kill, rogue".

I sent my message at 2:36 AM

I bcc'ed it to everyone in the game, and here's who replied to me and when (with brief summaries of what they said):

aok 2:42 am
Requested information that he says only mafia would know

Miranda Gavrin 11:12 am
Do you have my next target? Also, add me to mafia forums!

tjhance 12:53 pm
I can convince ltchin and lopezv to give me their roles, but it would seem sketchy... Also, add me to mafia forums!

lopezv 2:23 pm
I have [item]. Come prove you're mafia to me in person!


I don't think that this makes anyone any more or less suspicious, it was mostly me trying to annoy the mafia/rogue and make fun of ksedlar giving everyone a kill target (If she can tell everyone who to kill, I can tell everyone they succeeded!)

If anyone has any other opinions of whether or not these results were useful, post them here...

The full text of my response was



Obviously (and this will be everybody's excuse) I was playing along to see if we could find out who the mafia were. However, the people on here are probably more likely to actually be rogue than a randomly chosen person.

Also, I'm not going to comment on the truthhood/falsehood of anything I said in my response

Other things to consider:

-Rogue might not have made that kill
-Rogue might have been found without even making a kill, if he's the only one who lied about their target
-Mafia might have messaged rogue before they responded to me, telling them I'm a fake
-Timing-wise, I expect the people who responded today to have been asleep when I sent out the message. All that I think this proves is that aok was awake when the kill was made (which he admitted to in his alibi anyways...)

Also, I paraphrased the responses to make sure I didn't reveal any details, specifically from aok and lopezv's responses. If they're townies and thought I was mafia, they're likely lying in their messages to me. Should I just post the full responses? My only worry from doing so is that it might give the mafia some amount of information (from knowing these things are false)...

I was reverse-trolling Kemus on the off chance that he was actually a stupid mafia instead of an intelligent townie. Because I anticipated this exact thread, I PMed DGrazian and Ellena with the text of Kemus' PM before I knew whether everyone had gotten one. They can vouch that I said I was going to fake claim.

I can vouch for Miranda on this.

Seconded.