kaima wrote:
So to me, EITHER the murderer was a Random regular, OR the press was manipulated into placing suspicion on Random regulars, specifically the four that Daniel named. However, I don't have enough information to go on.
Daniel named the four after the murder happened, so I don't think that line of reasoning quite works...
I'm still a little miffed by the anonymous/illegal "investigator" outburst, since it really threw off some of my suspicions. But look at it this way:
Scenario 1: investigator is really a Mafia member
--> they probably posted hoping that suspicion would be thrown off of Kate (who, in this case, would probably be a fellow mafia)
Scenario 2: investigator is the actual investigator
--> Then we have two options. In both cases, most likely they actually did an investigation and came out with a negative and were completely telling the truth.
--> HOWEVER, this could either mean that Kate IS or ISN'T mafia - keep in mind there are FOUR of them, so she could very well be one herself even if she didn't make the kill
JRC, do you have any other reason for Lydia besides my mention that she didn't really contribute?
Until I have further evidence, I will be
voting for Kate.