lol you can not be in contact with rogues and still know your the last natural born mafia. Don't all the mafia automatically connect in the start?
Your cynic argument is basically that Mafia are stupid, hence I am a cynic. I really don't think we can rely on Mafia being altogether that stupid without good reason. it's far more likely that you were just caught for a kill.
I mean at this point, given how shady you appear to us, as a townie and a good player, you would have also probably suggested that we try killing you and see what happens. We've made the argument for lynching whoever definitely came up positive before. We must lynch you. You're too damn shady. And town will still win, which is what everyone wants in the end of course
ltchin wrote:
Ok, so these assumptions don't really hold up to logic.
More likely situations:
1. Assume I'm an innocent Town Cynic. I've been royally screwed by Framing, but mafia has been so fail that they shot themselves in the foot and lost 4 scum in 3 days (kevinaer, michikyo, Pesto, vlonge) which extends my lifespan by 2 days apparently.
2. Assume I'm a rogue that is not in contact with the Mafia or had been Framed by Mafia. If Mafia had framed me in the first place or did not know that I was rogue, why would they lose so many members to keep me off in the chopping block? They thought that I was a townie anyways, so there would be no need for them to "save" me
3. Assume I'm a rogue in contact with the Mafia. A rogue life is less important than a natural born mafia, so who cares if I die? Then why would the mafia chase so much good money (vlonge, Pesto) after a useless, sketchyAF, going-to-die rogue anyways?
I clearly posit that 1) is the most likely scenario. Nothing else really makes sense.