sammyluo wrote:
-Re 2): What don powers?
(Assuming Shi-Ke killed ksedlar)
-Trap is not even necessary given they didn't make any other kill today. They could've been planning to try, though.
Oops, you're right, trap wouldn't have been necessary, but I wouldn't discount the possibility of them having used it, because why not. Shike couldn't have been Don, because he turned up guilty for killing ksedlar.
Quote:
-With Shi-Ke and Luke as the two killers, what other evidence is there for kmath being mafia? Not saying there isn't any, just asking for a quantification. Is it mostly just the arguing against lynching Shi-Ke on day 1?
That, plus the likelihood that Shike would have wanted to conscript kmath (or vice versa), given that they're dating and both of them being mafia would make it much easier to make kills, or just wanting to be on the same side.
Quote:
I don't think the lukesci incident increases probability kmath is mafia, by any means.
Maybe not, but it sure as hell doesn't decrease the probability that kmath is mafia, at least in my opinion. If kmath is mafia, the lukesci incident would have been the perfect thing to make people less suspicious of her / less inclined to lynch her. She also suggested to me via pm (before it became publicly known that Luke shoveled as SK) that I tase her secretly, so that if a kill happened while she was tased (assuming Luke was mafia and there were 2 mafia left before Luke's death), she would be proven innocent. This clearly wouldn't work, if Luke was a SK, but it seems like the sort of contrived thing that mafia-kmath would come up with to throw people off.
Kmath, if you're actually innocent, I'm sorry, but I think you're sketchy af and nothing you've done so far has changed that opinion.