Literally the only thing that could go wrong for us is dpalumbo having been the mafia killer who killed Jackie. Then he could kill her again and we'd have to endure another loop. If dpalumbo is not a killer, it is impossible for us to lose this Loop without active self-sabotage or multiple townspeople forgetting to vote.
Also, if Troy kills dpalumbo, Jackie is still alive, and dpalumbo hasn't said, "boo" to Tin or Troy*, then we PROVABLY win this loop with the following actions: Pravina does NOT boo anyone today. We vote to lynch Lily Chen today. We vote to lynch Daniel Grazian tomorrow. (Probably irrelevant) Lotta boos herself every day to keep from dying. (Probably irrelevant) We goodwill vote in some way that does not lead to Jackie getting goodwill, e.g. everyone votes for me, brunnerj, Tin, and isaacg.
We cannot lose any lynch vote because we have a majority by a significant margin. We cannot lose via the day 3 culprit triggering because its Pravina, who will die at day end from not booing anyone We cannot lose via the day 4 culprit triggering because all possible mafia-aligned culprits are dead, and the only possible living town-aligned culprits (Troy and Tin) cannot be given enough paranoia by mafia (max is Lily banana-bread and Dgrazian boo today, Dgrazian boo tomorrow, which is 3 paranoia, and Troy and Tin currently have 0 paranoia). We cannot lose via Jackie using a gun because she doesn't have goodwill)
* Note: If dpalumbo DOES say boo to Troy or Tin today, then if either Lily or Dgrazian doesn't incant that person by the end of day, we can prove the win tonight; if they do, we have Troy kill the paranoid person tomorrow. So we can 100% win, but it's not a satisfactory game end proof because we don't have the exact information now.
|