I would like to see Nurse Joy investigate {Dgrazian, ermain}->sashacf today.
Given last night (and the confidence that Pravina was actually out of town / that the Squares people couldn't have missed one of them being gone), I'm pretty confident that one of the following is true: a. Matt was mafia and killed Sasha b. Erin was mafia and killed Sasha, and Professor Oak is mafia c. Aok and Dgrazian are both mafia, one of them killed Sasha, and Professor Oak is mafia (In b. Professor Oak is mafia for having lied about ermain being innocent, and in c. Professor Oak is mafia because otherwise aok wouldn't have proposed Dgrazian as the lynch.)
Making a further bet that Nurse Joy and Professor Oak are probably not both mafia (i.e. that we have at least one alive, active investigator), we can get some further cases upon my suggested investigation:
Case 1 (Nurse Joy investigates {Dgrazian, ermain}->sashacf and gets that ermain is innocent): a. Matt was mafia and killed Sasha b. Aok and Dgrazian are mafia, Dgrazian killed Sasha, and Professor Oak is mafia If we get this result and Professor Oak's proxy chain does not start with either aok or Dgrazian, then a. is true.
Case 2 (Nurse Joy investigates {Dgrazian, ermain}->sashacf and gets that ermain is innocent): a. Matt was mafia and killed Sasha b. Erin was mafia and killed Sasha, and Professor Oak is mafia If we get this result, then b seems more likely to be true (Joy's investigation revealing that aok was innocent was presumably on {ermain, aok}, so while ermain could have been unlucky twice, b looks right).
|