Pesto wrote:
I attempted to kill Josh Tuesday at Squares, in the review tip. We were in adjacent squares; I reached over to his square while he was looking away, tapped his shoulder (reasonably hard), and said bang (in a normal level of voice, but there was music on there background). Immediately after that, the next call was called, so I didn't hear whether he said disarm. He says he's still alive, and hasn't contacted me. I don't know whether:
1. He's a townie who didn't notice the kill,
2. He noticed that a kill was attempted and disarmed it, but didn't see who banged him and so can't contact me, or
3. He disarmed me and just hasn't thought to contact me.
If it's case 1, I'm not sure whether that means the kill just didn't happen (since I needed to be clear enough about it) or whether Josh is dead but doesn't know it yet (since the fact that he's sort of oblivious shouldn't give him extra protection from kills). Because of that, I haven't contacted him to check about cases 2 and 3, or to coordinate on alibis and such.
I think the kill should count. Thoughts? We're the mods, so the decision will be made by vote among us. (Obviously, vote to preserve game funness, not to support your side.)