In my defence: 1) I had no role information of Jackie's. Jackie knew my role, and wanted to set up a plot with it, hence me not being lynched the first night. I will happily role reveal, and can explain why she suggested the kill might look trappy. 2) That said, the kill didn't look trappy, which is, I think, a point in my favor. 3) If I am bad, am I mafia or PK? I think it is established that I did not personally kill Jackie. A) If I am mafia, I am sketchy for Jackie dying at the hands of one of my mafia buddies. But then why are all of my alibis so crappy? I would have better alibis for kills I was making or expecting. In particular, I would have either stayed longer at lunch with jamb/ritagram/lukesci or tried to find a player to hang out with in the afternoon, under the assumption that one of those kills was mafia. B) If I am PK, I am not sketchy for Jackie dying, because I did not personally kill Jackie. 4) A single pair investigation isn't super reliable, especially given that brunnerj isn't super sketchy. If you believe I made that kill, can you make more investigations first, ideally with sketchier people? I didn't make it (and would have a more interesting alibi if I did). 5) From what I've heard from other people I sometimes give off a more-sketchy-than-average-person vibe (both in mafia and irl). I'm sad about dgrazian deciding that I'm suspicious based on conversation with me, because we haven't really conversed before and he has no base point to judge my sketchiness. 6) What happened with Linus? Why was I against lynching Linus as opposed to keeping my head down and going with the flow? I think if I were mafia, that is what I would do, assuming Linus was town. It's possible that Linus was conscripted and so I didn't want him dead, but given the lynch mob, I would simply be sketchier by association and almost certainly fail at swaying the vote, which is not a thing a mafia would do.
|