michael_ma wrote:
michael_ma wrote:
My Splitter Investigation today: {Julian, Jakob}-->jbrunner returns Jakob innocent.
I put this in investigation proxying as well
Well this is quite surprising. I see three possibilities:
- Jakob manipulated the kill to make himself appear innocent. A mafia planeswalker, secret admirer, or priest could all do this.
- A priest put jakob as saint and brunnerj as sinner on day 1, which would be a very reasonable thing to do
- michael_ma is lying
The third one makes more sense to me than pravi lying, for example, because this pair investigation fairly opportunistic now that pravi posted this shovel. I also don't think his reasoning afterwards makes sense. I was hesitant to advise him to post on forum because it gives significant role information to the mafia, and so neuters jack's power significantly since he can be trapped. I asked who knew to try to guess whether the mafia already knew about it.