So the only people left untrapped are ahkim, jaysonl, and pppillai.
It was implied to me that pppillai is a doppelganger, so unless she killed max, she currently has no classical role and we can't trap her

. If she did kill max, we know he was a stalker day 3 so we can try that? It's a long shot though cause he easily could have changed roles since then and she probably didn't even kill him...
One thing of note, ajliu did proxy for an infallible investigation which could only have been from a gay knight as best I can tell; the only other source is police officer which has never exists, none of the items on the list grant them. This is curious since nobody has ever died of lovesickness; therefore their partner probably died of other causes, likely kaboom or lynch?
Otherwise, all we really have to work with is that ahkim wasn't a priest yesterday, which is really not much. I haven't heard of almost anyone being cynic, so on the theory that they actually exist at all, we should maybe try one of {ahkim, jaysonl} as cynic? I'd say ahkim since we know she's at least not priest?